The Karate Kid


In recent years we’ve seen a predominance of films, cult classics or otherwise be mined for potential in terms of remakes. Whether it’s simply due to the goodwill involved in the original concept and calculated risk or a lack of original material capable of development I’m not sure but the stakes can often be daunting when fighting to warrant their existence against the original.

Dre Parker (Jaden Smith) and his mother Sherry (Tajari P Henson) are forced to move to Beijing when her job at a Detroit car manufacturer demands it of them. Not long after arriving Dre tries to impress the young violinist Mei Ying (Wen Wen Han) in the local playground, attracting the negative attentions of Cheng (Zhenwei Wang) and his motley crew of kung fu prodigies. After one particular confrontation in which he is saved by the building repairman Mr Han (Jackie Chan), Dre inadvertadly enters himself into the local kung fu tournament, enduring hours of laborious training with his new teacher Han.

Attempting to dismiss the change in location and even the art he learns, director Harald Zwart manages to dismiss large portions of chinese culture because after all, “karate, kung fu – whatever”. Because we all know how wonderful relations are between China and Japan. Again and again, they try to reassure us this is a universal theme and largely they’re right but boiling two cultures down to “you’re Yoda and I’m like, a Jedi” doesn’t even comes close to sensitivity.

In terms of story little has changed, except for the addition of a now excessive running time of over two hours, a fact that may prove to be egregious with the younger target audience here. Every so often we are treated to a beautiful touristic insight into the well established sights of the country, adding little to assuage the fears of blatant stereotyping.

One uncertain alteration comes in the form of the previously mentioned target audience, meaning our protagonist is transformed from a relatively fully-formed teenager into a rather sass-ridden twelve year old. Such vulnerability of age and stature results in the bullying becoming a more believable element yet causes practically every other to suffer. The Mei Ying romance for example, cannot carry any real gravitas as neither is an a position to make it believable or even fully realized. One such attempt to do so, provided by a local folk tale enters shaky ground when it suddenly becomes too adult.

Action suffers equally as much from the same key point as the skills these children possess feel outlandish, unfitting of their youth and naiveté. This loss is more palpable than anything as the sequences and fights are well timed, edited and choreographed but are never genuine due to the simple fact that even if we could believe they could take such a torrent of physical abuse, why we would want to make children into such characters is of equal concern.

Smith and Cheng are the least comfortable on screen out of the entire cast from an acting perspective, the first relying on awkward chatter and the latter reduced to grimaces not even Nuclear Man would resort to. Henson, an actress I have long respected for works including “Benjamin Button” is written into a corner somewhere between shrill cheerleading and psychotropic optimism, never allowed to flex any real muscle.

While I can respect the efforts gone to create a new and worthwhile addition to the existing legacy, I can’t shake off the feeling that with an older base set of characters and a tighter narrative it could have succeeded. Instead there is one not quite like the others, for all the wrong reasons.

Advertisements
  1. I swear you must have eaten a dictionary at some stage. Or at least have a thesaurus open beside you. That’s why I like reading your reviews Charles – you have a wonderful ability to put the right word in the right place.

    Moving on – doesn’t sound like a film I’m going to be rushing out to see – a DVD watch on a quiet night perhaps? What makes the two hours plus that bit draining – is it just the fact you’re waiting for the final fight scene because you know it’s coming – i.e. if you hadn’t seen the original, would it still be tough to sit through?

      • thejackanory
      • August 18th, 2010

      Lol thanks, I rarely get so many compliments.

      Well it is a universal story, even if you put it up against say a dance movie where there’s an audition or recital at the end, you are waiting for the final conflict and the amount of diversions in this are just too many.
      It’s just a strange movie in how they kept the story almost identical to the original but changed all the key concepts – if you dig up the foundations of a house and put a new one down, no matter how shiny and pretty it is, without the same support it’s not going to stand up for long. That’s why the dismissive attitude to the alterations got to me, they want to just ignore them.

      I mean this thing is being marketed elsewhere as “The Kung Fu Kid” so it often appears as a wolf in sheep’s clothing.

  2. Yeah very good post. Was thinking of going to see it but opted for The A-Team instead. May rent it whenever it comes out just to see it. Cheers . . .

      • thejackanory
      • August 18th, 2010

      Thanks man. Yeah, having seen The A-Team as well you definitely made the right choice. If they had even shaved a good deal of time of the movie it’d have been better, really overstays its welcome and would seem counter-intuitive considering they’re marketing it at young kids.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: